What confuses me is this: I'm pretty sure I've watched every episode from every series in perfect chronological order, in fact I properly lost in lost lol. However, the “previously on lost” catch up section at the begining of s05e10 shows a deshevelled Richard discussing with Child Ben in the forest about how he wishes to defect to the others from the Dharma initiative. I have never seen this before and like I say I have watched every second so far. So is it something shit like here in the uk we only get an edited version, hioghly unlikely as uk law dictates that we have no more than 12 mins of advertisments per hour whereas in the US it's something unbelievably gay like 25 mins (they'd never get away with that over here – don't know why our us counterparts stand for it). Or is it that it never happened? Someone must know…

That scene is from season 3, I am in the Uk and that is most definitely in the Ben flashback episode towards the end of season 3. An absolutely brilliant episode that is.

@thatranga
i clearly remember seeing the richard and ben scene at the beginning before in previous episodes. they had showed it a couple episodes back and it was the episode when they showed how ben killed his father and the hostiles (others) killed the dharma initiative.